BLT Fish Sandwiches

3
(4 ratings)
Prep
Time
Total Time
Number Of
Ingredients
7
Servings4

A fish sandwich made special by adding bacon, lettuce, tomato and spicy brown mustard

Sale items for:
Ingredients
  • PAM® Original No-Stick Cooking Spray on sale
    5 local deals for
    PAM Original No-Stick Cooking Spray
    Pam Cooking Spray No-Stick, Original
    Selected Varieties Only
    $2.99 thru 2015-08-06
    Waldbaum's

    Pam Cooking Spray for Grilling, High Temperature Formula
    Excludes Professional, Organic and Coconut, Assorted Varieties, 5-6 oz., with card
    $2.99 thru 2015-08-06
    A&P

    Pam Cooking Spray No-Stick, Original
    Excludes Professional, Organic and Coconut, Assorted Varieties, 5-6 oz.
    $2.99 thru 2015-08-06
    Pathmark

    Pam Cooking Spray Original No-Stick, 2 Pack
    Based on Regular In-store Prices, Selected Varieties Only
    $2.00 OFF thru 2015-08-02
    Costco

    Pam Cooking Spray No-Stick, Original
    For Grilling, Butter Flavor, Olive Oil, or Original, 5-6 Oz. Can
    $3.49 thru 2015-08-06
    C-Town Supermarkets

  • 4 tilapia fillets (4 oz each), thawed if frozen on sale
    9 local deals for
    Tilapia
    Tilapia Fillets
    Fresh Cut
    1 lb For $3.99 thru 2015-08-06
    Morton Williams

    Tilapia Fillets
    Farm Raised, Thawed
    1 lb For $3.99 thru 2015-08-06
    C-Town Supermarkets

    Tilapia Fillets

    1 lb For $7.99 thru 2015-08-06
    Waldbaum's

    Trident Tilapia Fillets Frozen, Lemon Herb
    Or Dinner. Selected Varieties, 1902685. bonus buy savings, with your card
    1 ea For $4.99 thru 2015-08-06
    Stop & Shop

    Tilapia Fish Fillets, Fresh
    Milk Flaky, White Fish, Extremely Versatile, Can Be Baked, Grilled or Fried, Fresh
    1 lb For $7.99 thru 2015-08-06
    A&P

    Tilapia Fillets
    2 LBS.
    1 lb For $7.99 thru 2015-08-06
    Western Beef

    Tilapia Fillets
    Fresh, Milk Flaky, White Fish, Extremely Versatile, Can Be Baked, Grilled or Fried
    1 lb For $7.99 thru 2015-08-06
    A&P

    Tilapia Fillets
    Fishermans Net Fresh, farm raised Exclusively at ACME Fisherman’s Net seafood VARIETY. HUGE ANNIVERSARY Sale
    1 lb For $7.99 thru 2015-08-06
    Acme Markets

    Tilapia Fillets
    Great American Family Pack Fillets or Top Catch Variety Pack, Excludes Breaded Crunchy Shrimp, Frozen, Assorted Varieties 32-48 oz.
    $9.99 thru 2015-08-06
    Pathmark

  • 1/4 teaspoon ground black pepper on sale
    2 local deals for
    ground black pepper
    McCormick Black Peppercorn Grinder
    Assorted Varieties, .77-2.39 oz., with card
    2 For $5.00 thru 2015-08-06
    A&P

    McCormick Black Peppercorn Grinder
    Assorted Varieties, .77-2.39 oz.
    2 For $5.00 thru 2015-08-06
    Pathmark

  • 1/4 cup light mayonnaise on sale
    11 local deals for
    fat-free mayonnaise
    Hellmann's Mayonnaise Real
    Assorted Varieties, BUY 2 GET 1 FREE INSTANTLY Americas Choice Canned Tuna, 5 oz., Solid White or Chunk Light
    $6.00 for 2 thru 2015-08-06
    Pathmark

    Hellmann's Mayonnaise Reduced Fat
    30-36 fl. oz., Assorted Varieties, Save up to $2.11, LIMIT 2 OFFERS PER FAMILY, CLUB CARD PRICE
    $2.88 thru 2015-08-06
    Foodtown

    Hellmann's Real Mayonnaise Squeeze Bottle
    Assorted Varieties, BUY 2 GET 1 FREE INSTANTLY Americas Choice Canned Tuna, 5 oz., Solid White or Chunk Light
    $6.00 for 2 thru 2015-08-06
    Pathmark

    Kraft Mayo Mayonnaise Real Mayo
    1943698. SAVE $6 when you spend $20 on participating products. In a single transaction with your Stop & Shop card from 7/31–8/6/15. Limit 1 offer per transaction. bonus buy saving, with your card
    $2.99 thru 2015-08-06
    Stop & Shop

    Hellmann's Mayonnaise Real
    Selected Varieties Only
    2 For $6.00 thru 2015-08-06
    Waldbaum's

    Hellmann's Mayonnaise Canola, Cholesterol Free
    BUY 2, GET 1 Americas Choice, Canned Tuna, Solid White or Chunk Light 5 oz. FREE INSTANTLY, with card
    2 For $6.00 thru 2015-08-06
    A&P

    Hellmann's Mayonnaise Real

    $3.99 thru 2015-08-06
    Western Beef

    Hellmann's Real Mayonnaise Squeeze Bottle
    Assorted Varieties, Save up to $2.11, LIMIT 2 OFFERS PER FAMILY, CLUB CARD PRICE
    $2.88 thru 2015-08-06
    Foodtown

    Kraft Mayo Mayonnaise Real Mayo, Squeeze Bottle
    1943698. SAVE $6 when you spend $20 on participating products. In a single transaction with your Stop and Shop card from 7/31–8/6/15. Limit 1 offer per transaction. bonus buy saving, with your card
    $2.99 thru 2015-08-06
    Stop & Shop

    Hellmann's Real Mayonnaise Squeeze Bottle
    BUY 2, GET 1 Americas Choice, Canned Tuna, Solid White or Chunk Light 5 oz. FREE INSTANTLY, with card
    2 For $6.00 thru 2015-08-06
    A&P

    Hellmann's Real Mayonnaise Squeeze Bottle

    $4.99 thru 2015-08-06
    Kings Super Markets

  • 1 tablespoon Gulden's® Spicy Brown Mustard on sale
    4 local deals for
    brown mustard
    Guldens Mustard Zesty Honey
    Selected Varieties Only
    10 For $10.00 thru 2015-08-06
    Waldbaum's

    Guldens Mustard Brown, Spicy
    Your Choice, mix or match, OR $1.00 EACH
    10 For $10.00 thru 2015-08-06
    Pathmark

    Guldens Mustard Zesty Honey
    Assorted Varieties
    $0.88 thru 2015-08-06
    Food Basics

    Guldens Mustard Zesty Honey

    2 For $3.00 thru 2015-08-06
    Kings Super Markets

  • 4 soft hoagie rolls (about 6 inches)
  • 4 leaves green leaf lettuce
  • 4 slices fully cooked bacon on sale
    27 local deals for
    thick-sliced bacon
    Farmland Bacon Thick Sliced
    Selected Varieties Only
    $3.99 thru 2015-08-13
    Waldbaum's

    Farmland Bacon Thick Sliced
    New, Assorted varieties, With Card.
    $3.99 thru 2015-08-13
    A&P

    Farmland Bacon Thick Sliced

    $3.99 thru 2015-08-08
    Pioneer

    Farmland Bacon Hickory Smoked
    or Low Salt
    $4.99 thru 2015-08-06
    C-Town Supermarkets

    Oscar Mayer Hearty Thick Cut Bacon
    2.52 oz., with card
    2 For $7.00 thru 2015-08-13
    A&P

    Oscar Mayer Bacon Smoked Butcher, Thick Slice

    3 For $4.98 thru 2015-08-06
    Foodtown

    Bacon Regular
    Foodtown, 16 Oz., Save up to $2.11 Ea., LIMIT 2 OFFERS PER FAMILY, CLUB CARD PRICE
    1 lb For $2.88 thru 2015-08-06
    Foodtown

    Bacon Regular
    12 OZ.
    3 lb For $10.00 thru 2015-08-06
    Western Beef

    Bacon Sliced
    Smithfield, Selected Varieties, 16 oz. pkg. 1941087, bonus buy savings, with your card
    2 lb For $7.00 thru 2015-08-06
    Stop & Shop

    Butterball Turkey Bacon Everyday Lower Sodium

    $2.99 thru 2015-08-06
    Morton Williams

    Oscar Mayer Bacon Turkey, Smoked Cured Dark & White Turkey Chopped and Formed

    $2.99 thru 2015-08-08
    Pioneer

    Oscar Mayer Bacon Turkey, Smoked Cured Dark & White Turkey Chopped and Formed
    Selected Varieties Only
    2 For $6.00 thru 2015-08-13
    Waldbaum's

    Butterball Turkey Bacon Everyday Lower Sodium
    Selected Varieties Only
    2 For $6.00 thru 2015-08-13
    Waldbaum's

    Oscar Mayer Bacon Maple
    Selected Varieties Only
    $3.94 thru 2015-08-15
    Walmart Supercenter

    Oscar Mayer Bacon Turkey, Lower Sodium with Sea Salt
    Selected Varieties, 11.5–12 oz. pkg. 1923471, with your card
    1 ea For $2.99 thru 2015-08-06
    Stop & Shop

    Oscar Mayer Bacon Turkey, Lower Sodium with Sea Salt
    Select, 11-12 oz. with card
    2 For $6.00 thru 2015-08-13
    A&P

    Oscar Mayer Bacon Turkey, Lower Sodium with Sea Salt
    11-12 oz., Regular or Select
    2 For $6.00 thru 2015-08-13
    Pathmark

    Butterball Turkey Bacon Everyday Lower Sodium

    3 For $4.98 thru 2015-08-06
    Foodtown

    Tyson Hickory Smoked Bacon Natural Smoked
    Assorted Varieties
    $4.49 thru 2015-08-06
    Foodtown

    Wright Bacon Applewood, Stack Pack
    Includes All Varieties
    $6.99 thru 2015-08-06
    Kings Super Markets

    Butterball Turkey Bacon Everyday Lower Sodium

    $1.99 thru 2015-08-06
    Western Beef

    Butterball Turkey Bacon Thin & Crispy

    $1.99 thru 2015-08-06
    Western Beef

    Boars Head Naturally Smoked Sliced Bacon
    2.29 oz. Package. Fully Cooked Gluten Free
    $5.49 thru 2015-08-06
    Morton Williams

    Oscar Mayer Bacon Ready to Serve, Fully Cooked, Two 30 Count packs
    2.52 oz., Original or Thick Cut
    2 For $7.00 thru 2015-08-13
    Pathmark

    Hormel Bacon Microwave-Ready

    $6.99 thru 2015-08-13
    A&P

    Oscar Mayer Bacon Pre-Cooked
    Selected Varieties Only, Loyalty Card Required
    2 For $7.00 thru 2015-08-13
    Waldbaum's

    Oscar Mayer Bacon Pre-Cooked
    Original, with card
    2 For $7.00 thru 2015-08-13
    A&P

  • 4 slices tomato, each cut in half on sale
    17 local deals for
    fresh tomatoes
    Tomatoes Vine Ripe, Regular

    1 lb For $1.49 thru 2015-08-06
    C-Town Supermarkets

    Tomatoes Vine Ripe, Regular
    Fresh, Great in Summer Salads
    1 lb For $1.99 thru 2015-08-06
    Pathmark

    Tomatoes Beef / Beefsteak
    SAVE UP TO $1/LB.
    1 lb For $0.99 thru 2015-08-06
    Fairway

    Tomatoes Regular Grape
    1 pint/pkg.
    $0.99 thru 2015-08-06
    Hmart

    Tomatoes Vine Ripe
    Premium Quality 1973196, with your card
    1 lb For $1.49 thru 2015-08-06
    Stop & Shop

    Tomatoes Regular Grape
    Red Ripe. Container
    2 pt For $5.00 thru 2015-08-06
    Morton Williams

    Tomatoes Grape, Organic
    Natures Promise. 16 oz. cont., 1972671, bonus buy savings. with your card
    1 ea For $2.99 thru 2015-08-06
    Stop & Shop

    Tomatoes Greenhouse
    Sunset Angel Sweet, 1.5 lb. ctn. fresh PRODUCE & FLORAL. HUGE ANNIVERSARY Sale
    1 ea For $5.00 thru 2015-08-06
    Acme Markets

    America's Choice Stewed Tomatoes Italian Style
    Canned, Assorted Varieties, with card
    $0.89 thru 2015-08-13
    A&P

    Tomatoes Plum / Italian / Saladette / Roma

    1 lb For $1.28 thru 2015-08-06
    Food Basics

    Tomatoes Plum / Italian / Saladette / Roma

    1 lb For $1.38 thru 2015-08-15
    Walmart Supercenter

    Tomatoes Beef / Beefsteak
    Extra Large. Jersey
    1 lb For $1.49 thru 2015-08-08
    Pioneer

    Tomatoes Plum / Italian / Saladette / Roma On The Vine
    Premium. Great Tasting, 1972817, bonus buy savings. with your card
    1 lb For $1.99 thru 2015-08-06
    Stop & Shop

    Tomatoes Greenhouse / Hydroponic / Regular
    Premium One Sweet, Sweet and Firm, 16 oz. pkg., 1972701, bonus buy savings. with your card
    2 For $5.00 thru 2015-08-06
    Stop & Shop

    Tomatoes Regular
    Organic, on the Vine, USDA ORGANIC natural and ORGANIC. HUGE ANNIVERSARY Sale
    1 lb For $2.99 thru 2015-08-06
    Acme Markets

    Tomatoes Heirloom
    Locally Grown, WE LOVE LOCAL LOCALLY GROWN PRODUCE fresh PRODUCE & FLORAL. HUGE ANNIVERSARY Sale
    1 lb For $2.99 thru 2015-08-06
    Acme Markets

    Tomatoes Heirloom
    Organic
    1 lb For $4.99 thru 2015-08-06
    Kings Super Markets

Directions
  1. Spray large nonstick skillet with cooking spray; heat over medium-high heat. Sprinkle fish with pepper. Place in skillet; cook 8 minutes or until fish flakes easily with fork (145°F), turning once.
  2. Meanwhile, combine mayonnaise and mustard in small bowl. Spread 1 tablespoon mustard mixture on bottom half of each roll.
  3. Place lettuce leaves and fish fillets on bottom halves of rolls. Top each with 1 slice bacon and 2 pieces tomato. Close sandwiches with top halves of rolls. Serve immediately.
I made This!

Share your experience now

Nutrition Information
Calories: 394 View complete nutrition information
Reviews (4)

Your review of BLT Fish Sandwiches

Thank You!

You have successfully submitted your rating or review for this recipe. If you submitted a review, please note that it might take up to 72 hours for your review to appear on our site.

Jaime January 09, 2012

This recipe is easy and delicious. It was perfect portions for just my father and myself. I would recommend it to others.

Anonymous December 15, 2011

This recipe is super easy, fast, and delicious. I would definitely recommend it for others.

FOODe July 18, 2011

This recipe was easy and fast to make and healthful too! In fact, I was pleasantly surprised to find that I could enjoy this meal while on my 17-Day Diet. All I had to do was omit the bun. The other thing that I enjoyed about this recipe was that I had every ingredient needed already in my kitchen! No need to make a special grocery trip, and that's a HUGE bonus in my hectic household. I'd definitely make this again.

MizFitOnline June 14, 2011

This recipe was a semi-hit at our house...but with a lot of tweaking to 'make it ours.' I knew when I selected it that my Husband would adore the sandwich. He loves tilapia. He loves sandwiches. For him this was perfection without any changes to the recipe. For the five year old the recipe was PERFECT in its preparation. She had so much fun (as I watched her like a hawk) cooking the fish, mixing the spread and assembling the sandwiches. When it came to eating time she and I ended up with the same thing on our places: Im gluten free and decided against buying GF rolls and ate mine without spread on an "iceberg lettuce bun." She started out with a sandwich and deconstructed till she ended up the same way. She and I loved our tweaked tilapia lettuce-bun sandwiches and I would definitely make this again....with one sandwich and two tweaks!